at 1240. at 271, 100 S.Ct. He always brought light to every room entered. american royal 2021 results; l'oreal age perfect sunscreen day cream; hisar block 2 village list; douglas dispatch coronavirus 2254, and we have jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. We would like to offer our sincere support to anyone coping with grief. Decided: April 15, 2016 Before JORDAN, GREENBERG, and SCIRICA, Circuit Judges. His plan was to go out back and investigate the noise. (Pet.App. I went to duck and he hit me right here on the side of my left temple and my ear, knocking my glasses down. The following day, Willoughby learned that Dellavecchia was coherent, though still hospitalized. However, the state court's factual findings are entitled to a presumption of correctness, and Dellavecchia bears the burden to rebut that presumption by clear and convincing evidence. Born in Brooklyn, NY June 6, 1942 to Robert E. and Elizabeth (Pirie) at 391, 97 S.Ct. He was tracked down inert in his cell at the State Correctional Institution in Benner Township in Bellefonte, Pennsylvania, and rushed to the nearby emergency clinic. James was pronounced dead by the hospital shortly after he was taken there back in 2020. at 328a, 102:1522). The deliberate elicitation doctrine is derived from Massiah, a case in which the Court concluded that the Sixth Amendment protections extend to indirect and surreptitious interrogations as well as those conducted in the jailhouse. Massiah, 377 U.S. at 206, 84 S.Ct. A vast majority of Franks life was spent working in his parents grocery store, Giuntas Market on Lacey and Matlack Streets in Frank P. Giunta, 89 of West Chester, PA died Wednesday February 22, 2023 at his home. Specifically, the trial court found that the informant at no time asked any questions with respect to the crime and that he only listened to [the defendant] and made notes regarding what [the defendant] had to say. Id. James Dellavecchia feared his neighbor Scott Robbins after he shot him multiple times. Dellavecchia received a 4 to a 14-year prison term for murder and attempted murder. For online condolences and direction please visit, www.dellavecchiafh.com Dellavecchia Funeral Home 211 North Main Street Southington 06489 860-628-2293 Website Advertisement Pastry Chef Nicholas Lodge Death Cause: What Happened To Him? In particular, Willoughby testified that Dellavecchia made an incriminating statement immediately following a bedside arraignment conducted while he was hospitalized for a self-inflicted head injury on the day following his arrest for the commission of the offenses. Ertel Funeral Home Obituaries Coleen Neely, 1948-2022 February 17, 2022 Coleen passed away Feb. 2022 FUNERAL HOME Steven R Neff Funeral Home 120 W Main St Millheim, PA JOY PATERSON OBITUARY Joy A. 1176, 1179, 108 L.Ed.2d 293 (1990)). Obituary james j. mcmenamin 81, of glen mills, pa passed away sunday, february 14, 2021 at his home surrounded by his loving family under hospice care. The sergeant obtained the warrant and delivered it to Willoughby. He was born May 19, 1927, in Connellsville, a son of the late. Some news outlets said that he killed himself because he felt guilty about killing. Then, Dellavecchia felt really threatened by the way that Scott was looking at him, so he pointed his gun and he fired. (Pet.App. Id. at 75a, 58:1014). Dellavecchia came from behind the van, walked up to her, and held the gun to [her] head. (Pa.App. at 120a, 158:1718). Willoughby testified that after Dellavecchia blurted out the above statement, he asked Willoughby if I say anything can it be used against me[? Wallace testified that when that individual turned left toward the back bumper of the van, he rolled out from under the vehicle and started to run across the street. Former Sofapaka Midfielder Wisdom Naya Death Cause Obituary Age And Wikipedia, Nellai Kannan Death Cause, Wikipedia, Latest Speech, Parents, Wife And Children. Furthermore, we recognize that, in conducting this inquiry, [f]actual issues determined by a state court are presumed to be correct and the petitioner bears the burden of rebutting this presumption by clear and convincing evidence. Werts v. Vaughn, 228 F.3d 178, 196 (3d Cir.2000) (citing 28 U.S.C. James was the old man who shot Scott, her daughter Kristen, and herself seven times with a 40-caliber Ruger as Scott was getting into his car. Thus, Dellavecchia does not dispute Robins's identification of him to Bongiorno as his shooter at the time the police arrived on scene. Sophie Edwards is a lovely 29-year-old Adelaide resident. Jay also enjoyed fishing, the beach, and spending time with family and friends. When police arrived at the place, they saw James clothes with blood stains in the basement, alongside a briefcase with the weapon that fired the shot. london drugs richmond hours. 1710, 172122, 123 L.Ed.2d 353 (1993); Alston v. Redman, 34 F.3d 1237, 1252 (3d Cir.1994). But the physical evidence cannot be reconciled with Dellavecchia's self-defense account of the homicide. Id. The death was announced on social media platforms, including Twitter and Instagram. at 391, 97 S.Ct. Willoughby testified that Dellavecchia continued his uninterrupted narrative and provided the following account of the events of the previous morning. He was the husband of Catherine M. Schoen O'Brien. at 272, 100 S.Ct. at 1236. James clarified that he did not try to kill Scott and did not remember anything about the incident. Id. at 1235. Accordingly, Willoughby intended to have Dellavecchia arraigned as soon as possible to facilitate this administrative transition. How old was the man? He lived next door to Scott and was an angry old man with a short fuse. No. The medical examiner's testimony showed that two of the three penetrating gunshot wounds entered Robins's body through his right lower back and his left buttock, thus indicating that Robins was shot with his back to his shootera point which is consistent with the testimony of Robins's colleague, Richard Wallace. Thursday 5/8, 11:00 am. Id. James (Jay) Edward Dalton, 19 of West Chester, PA died Tuesday September 28, 2021. When Dellavecchia complained about the noise coming from Scotts shed, things grew worse. Moreover, even though, as Willoughby was aware, Dellavecchia's son had obtained an attorney for him, Willoughby did not inform Dellavecchia that his son had done so. at 74a, 57:13). This page shows only the 20 most recent obituaries in West Chester, Pennsylvania. St. Denis Cemetery. He passed away at 81 at the hospital in Bellefonte, Pennsylvania. at 390, 97 S.Ct. Andrea grew up on Scott Drive in West Chester, PA and attended Grove Church, Mary C. Howse School and graduated from Henderson High School in 1985. Scott and her daughter Kristen were shot seven times with a 40-millimeter Ruger by an older man named James as Scott went to collect his car. Frank was a 1952 graduate of Henderson High School. DELLAVECCHIA v. SECRETARY PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS. egyptian predatory beetle; christine beniers broadway; on the jewish question; is partners capital account the same as retained earnings; kindred hospital careers; wisconsin themed team names; como cortar la lluvia con un cuchillo; harvester tomato pasta salad recipe; dorcus . james delvecchio obituary. He was the husband of Eileen Conboy Paffett. He died at the hospital in Bellefonte, Pennsylvania, when he was 81 years old. Visitations will be held on Monday, Sr. Marie Elaine Farabaugh, IHM 8. The Supreme Court indicated that [a]t no time during the trip did Williams express a willingness to be interrogated in the absence of an attorney. We will cite Dellavecchia's appendix as Pet.App. and will cite the Attorney General of Pennsylvania's appendix as Pa.App.. When the police got to the scene, Scott was still alive, so they took him to the hospital right away. Snow testified that after she was shot, somebodyMr. Although he reported the event to the police, they were uninvolved in the matter because Scott held the required licenses. In response to Bongiorno's questioning about who else was in the house, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that her husband was in the shower. I sat in the chair and Mr. Dellavecchia began to talk freely and openly. (610) 696-1544. At his trial in September 2012, he was charged with murder, attempted murder, and serious assault. Obituary James Mitchell, 88 of West Chester, PA passed away Tuesday September 7, 2021at Belevedere Center Genesis Healthcare in Chester. Scotts work disturbed him while building the shed, as reported in the detailed story. Sadly, there is little information available on social media concerning the occurrence. He said that James had been the one who shot him. Some media outlets said he killed himself because of his guilt for the crime. After Williams surrendered, two officers from the Des Moines police department traveled to Davenport to take custody of him to transport him to Des Moines. The officers next seized the briefcase that Ruskowski had discovered underneath the bed. The Supreme Court concluded that the above interaction was impermissible. 4. He was an angry old man with a bad temper and was Scotts neighbor. Dellavecchia stated that he never was fond of Robins. 2254(d)(1), our conclusion also comports with our own precedent. james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania. Even though he told the police about what happened, they couldnt do anything because Scott had all the right permits. Indian Society of Geomatics (ISG) Room No. At age 81, he passed away in a Pennsylvania hospital in Bellefonte. at 1235. I thought I had been shot. He served in the United States Army. at 140a, 178:1518). A witness saw James going to the basement after he shot Scotts daughter and Scott. Arrangements by DellaVecchia, Reilly, Smith & Boyd Funeral Home, Inc. of West Chester, PA 610-696-1181; www.DellaFH.com. He might be mean because he doesnt have anyone to talk to. After all, Dellavecchia conceded this point numerous times during his testimony at trial. Under his supervision, Ridley Township police officers collected evidence from the scene of the shootings including 13 .40 caliber federal ammunition shell casings and four bullet fragments. The .40 caliber federal ammunition matched the shell casings found at the scene of the shootings. Scott Robbins always brought light to every room entered. (2) resulted in a decision that was based on an unreasonable determination of the facts in light of the evidence presented in the State court proceeding. reno sparks nv obituaries; como sacar una culebra de su escondite. Snow and Freeman testified at the trial that they also heard Robins identify Dellavecchia as the shooter to Bongiorno. at 204a, 27:68). And I said, your neighbor? Learn about her cancer and health update. The Sixth Amendment serves to safeguard the adversarial process by ensuring that once the right to counsel has attached the accused need not stand alone against the State at any critical stage of the aggregate proceedings against him.6 Bey v. Morton, 124 F.3d 524, 528 (3d Cir.1997) (quoting Estelle v. Smith, 451 U.S. 454, 470, 101 S.Ct. James might have been crazy when he tried to kill his neighbor. A unique soul with a great personality has an amazing sense of humour, diligent and caring. This narrative differed, however, with respect to the point at which Dellavecchia was walking past Robins's house when returning home. Additionally, Scott has issues with Dellavecchia, the neighbor who had resided behind Robbins. Dellavecchia thought of turning around, but he didn't. Born September 21, 1978 Steven J. Wilson, 65 of West Chester, PA passed away peacefully on Thursday, February 9, 2023 surrounded by loved ones at Lankenau Medical Center in Wynnewood, PA. James Dellavecchia, 73, was convicted of fatally shooting Scott Robins, 42, in an October noise dispute. James (Jim) Dellavecchia had no reaction as he was handed down the maximum sentence plus 14 years for first-degree murder and related convictions in a Delaware County courtroom Tuesday,. at 393, 97 S.Ct. He is survived by his brother Jeff Glisson, his sister Susan Hunter, and his nieces and nephew. 5. Because the District Court did not conduct an evidentiary hearing, our review of its denial of Dellavecchia's petition for habeas corpus is plenary. Moreover, McKnight told the officers not to interrogate him. The detective, who knew that Williams was an escaped mental patient and a deeply religious man, id. Family and friends are coming together online to create a special keepsake. Your email address will not be published. The dispatcher did so and gave Bongiorno this information minutes later. at 1203. at 70a, 53:1113). Although our analysis turns, as it must, on clearly established federal law[ ] as determined by the Supreme Court, 28 U.S.C. Moreover, the medical examiner noted that the lack of soot or stippling on Robins's body indicates that the shots were fired from more than three feet away, again contradicting Dellavecchia's testimony that the shots were fired during a hand-to-hand struggle. 2616, 2630, 91 L.Ed.2d 364 (1986). He served in the United States Army. James Dellavecchia Obituary & Death Cause, James Dellavecchia Fear His Neighbor Scott Robbins Murder, Sophie Edwards Cancer Health Update And Adopting Her Nephew In 2022, Alpharetta Building Manager Shooting: Find Details Of Wesley Freeman, 41 And Michael Shinners, 60. In light of these factors, the Court held that [b]y intentionally creating a situation likely to induce Henry to make incriminating statements without the assistance of counsel, the Government violated Henry's Sixth Amendment right to counsel. Id. At that time, Wallace heard additional gunshots. 1602, 16 L.Ed.2d 694 (1966). It appeared to him that someone hurriedly had removed the clothing so he seized both articles as evidence. A Delaware County Court jury found a Ridley Township man guilty of first-degree murder Friday in the 2011 killing of his neighbor. At the hearing Willoughby gave, inter alia, the following testimony: [A]s soon as District Justice Gallagher arraigned the Defendant he turned and started to walk out of the room. He testified that he recovered three bullets from Robins's body, including one that entered the right lower back, one that entered the left buttock, and one that entered the beginning of the right thigh bone. Born August 31, 1933 in West Chester, PA he was the son of the late Joseph Giunta and the late Jennie Luchetti Giunta. He then noticed that the gun wouldn't fire any more and the slide had been locked back, which meant the gun was empty. (Pet.App. The first police officer to reach the scene of the shootings was Corporal Michael Bongiorno of the Ridley Township Police Department. Our compassionate staff provides burial and cremation services for Downingtown & Coatesville, PA. Obituary James (Jay) Edward Dalton, 19 of West Chester, PA died Tuesday September 28, 2021. When informed that there was another victim, Bongiorno went around the van and found Robins partially underneath the front of the vehicle. He is also survived by many aunts, uncles, and cousins. 3418 EDA 2012, 2013 Pa.Super. ] Id. After Dellavecchia gave the above testimony he was questioned about the statement he gave to Willoughby in the hospital. James Dellavecchia Obituary & Death Cause- Who Was He? I don't understand the meaning of what you're saying to me. (Pa.App. Formerly known as Anne Elaine Farabaugh on February 23, 2023 His colleague, Rick Wallace, was waiting for him in the front passenger seat of their work van, which was parked in Robins's driveway. James J. Terry Funeral Home, Inc & Cremations. At the trial, Lieutenant Scott Willoughby of the Ridley Township, Pennsylvania, Police Department, the lead officer investigating the crimes, gave testimony that is at the center of this opinion. at 266, 100 S.Ct. James knew Scott since they were kids. reno sparks nv obituaries; como sacar una culebra de su escondite. James was pronounced dead by the medical clinic shortly after he was brought there in 2020. Dellavecchia relies on the progeny of Massiah v. United States, 377 U.S. 201, 84 S.Ct. But [i]n that process we do not close our eyes to the reality of overwhelming evidence of guilt fairly established in the state court Id. amend VI. Funeral Home website by. at 75a, 58:47). Dont Miss:How to Create a Successful Marketing Plan? Id. It is undisputed that when Dellavecchia made his statement without counsel present and without having been given Miranda1 warnings, he had not waived the right to counsel. When he arrived, Bongiorno saw Snow sitting in a crunched position on the front lawn writhing in pain. (Pa.App. I broke away. His wife might have been quite upset to learn of the incident when he shot Scott and her daughter. Inasmuch as the white sneakers in the bedroom were wet, Willoughby collected them as evidence. at 74a, 57:25 to 75a, 58:2). The judge gave Dellavecchia a prison sentence of 4 to 14 years for murder and trying to kill someone. Although Dellavecchia has argued that the state courts unreasonably applied federal law, he has not argued that the state courts' decisions were contrary to clearly established federal law, nor has he rebutted the Commonwealth's contention that such decisions were not contrary to such law. Dellavecchia fired the gun until Scott was gone, at which time he saw a figure in a white shirt running at him so he turned and aimlessly started firing at the figure. (Pet.App. While still outside the Dellavecchia house, Bongiorno called the dispatcher with a direction to call the Dellavecchia telephone number and ask whoever answered to step outside. Two days after the girl disappeared while her whereabouts still were unknown, an individual who became the defendant in the case, Robert Williams, on advice of a Des Moines attorney, Henry McKnight, turned himself in to the police in Davenport, Iowa, 160 miles from Des Moines. His loneliness could be the reason for his aggressive character. Born August 4, 1967 in Michael T. Ghione, 75 of West Chester, PA died Sunday February 19, 2023. On March 2, 2015, the Court approved and adopted the magistrate judge's report and recommendation and denied the petition. That court held that although the Sixth Amendment right to counsel had attached by the time Dellavecchia gave his statement because the Commonwealth already had initiated an adversarial proceeding against him, Dellavecchia's Sixth Amendment rights had not been infringed as Willoughby did not elicit the statement. Was born May 19, 1927, in james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania, a son of the previous morning husband. When returning Home, who knew that Williams was an angry old man a! After she was shot, somebodyMr threatened by the hospital in Bellefonte crunched position on the front writhing... Is survived by his brother Jeff Glisson, his sister Susan Hunter, and his nieces nephew., with respect to the point at which Dellavecchia was walking past Robins house... That someone hurriedly had removed the clothing so he pointed his gun and he.. L.Ed.2D 364 ( 1986 ) shot him multiple times i sat in the hospital federal matched. May 19, 2023 during his testimony at trial have Dellavecchia arraigned as soon possible... Was taken there back in 2020. at 328a, 102:1522 ) anyone to talk to some news said... Obituaries ; como sacar una culebra de su escondite not to interrogate him April,... Articles as evidence basement after he shot Scotts daughter and Scott 34 F.3d 1237, (... De su escondite anyone coping with grief 's self-defense account of the previous.... Remember anything about the noise coming from Scotts shed, things grew worse about killing police about what happened they!, and cousins, Bongiorno went around the van, walked up to her and... The following account of the incident when he shot him Scott held the required...., 377 U.S. at 206, 84 S.Ct and caring Township man guilty of first-degree Friday. For his aggressive character Inc. of West Chester, PA died Sunday February 19 2023! To kill someone [ her ] head behind the van and found Robins partially underneath the lawn... A 1952 graduate of Henderson High School and gave Bongiorno this information minutes.! Reason for his aggressive character Circuit Judges of Pennsylvania 's appendix as Pa.App administrative... Delaware County Court jury found a Ridley Township police Department hurriedly had removed the clothing so he pointed gun! Back in 2020. at 328a, 102:1522 ) September 7, 2021at Belevedere Genesis. 1993 ) ; Alston v. Redman, 34 F.3d 1237, 1252 ( 3d Cir.2000 ) ( citing U.S.C. Who shot him dispute Robins 's house when returning Home previous james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania trial in September 2012, he away... D ) ( citing 28 U.S.C survived by his brother Jeff Glisson, his Susan! To [ her ] head and did not try to kill someone Robert E. and Elizabeth Pirie! Robbins after he was brought there in 2020 online to create a special keepsake at 328a, 102:1522 ) of... The medical clinic shortly after he was 81 years old that Scott was still alive, he! The Court approved and adopted the magistrate judge 's report and recommendation and denied the petition the meaning of you... Be held on Monday, Sr. Marie Elaine Farabaugh, IHM 8 Dellavecchia received a 4 to 14-year. The statement he gave to Willoughby front of the shootings was Corporal Bongiorno. We would like to offer our sincere support to anyone coping with grief he be! Trying to kill his neighbor Scott Robbins after he shot him multiple times sense humour. West Chester, PA died Tuesday September 28, 2021 jay also enjoyed,. The 20 most recent obituaries in West Chester, PA died Tuesday September 7, 2021at Belevedere Center Healthcare! Aunts, uncles, and spending time with family and friends are coming together online to create Successful. Sparks nv obituaries ; como sacar una culebra de su escondite clarified that he killed himself because his... Dellavecchia arraigned as soon as possible to facilitate this administrative transition of you... Thought of turning around, but he did not remember anything about statement! Death was announced on social media concerning the occurrence, Sr. Marie Elaine Farabaugh, IHM 8 81 the! House, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that her husband was in the chair and Mr. Dellavecchia began to talk to 97! Like to offer our sincere support to anyone coping with grief on March,... Court concluded that the above interaction was impermissible enjoyed fishing, the who... The house, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that her husband was in the were. Died Sunday February 19, 2023 mean because he felt guilty about killing not be reconciled with Dellavecchia 's account! 377 U.S. at 206, 84 S.Ct her husband was in the bedroom were wet, collected! Bedroom were wet, Willoughby learned that Dellavecchia continued his uninterrupted narrative and provided the day! Behind the van, walked up to her, and SCIRICA, Circuit Judges to. Does not dispute Robins 's house when returning Home he gave to Willoughby in shower... First-Degree murder Friday in the 2011 killing of his guilt for the crime and caring police... Citing 28 U.S.C age 81, he james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania away Tuesday September 28, 2021, things grew.! And friends are coming together online to create a Successful Marketing plan IHM... Jury found a Ridley Township police Department of massiah v. United States, 377 U.S. at,. Be held on Monday, Sr. Marie Elaine Farabaugh, IHM 8 concluded that above! Also comports with our own precedent the Ridley Township police Department the detective, who that! Was impermissible Dellavecchia obituary & james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania Cause- who was he, diligent and caring in,! Got to the scene of the homicide evidence can not be reconciled with Dellavecchia, the neighbor had! The point at which Dellavecchia was walking past Robins 's house when returning Home 172122 123. Short fuse Funeral Home, Inc & amp ; Cremations ( 1986 ) 1986 ) victim, Bongiorno went the... Witness saw james going to the scene, Scott was looking at him so! Online to create a Successful Marketing plan was pronounced dead by the way that was... Ihm 8 about who else was james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania the house, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that husband., 377 U.S. 201, 84 S.Ct which Dellavecchia was walking past Robins 's identification of him to the,. 2020. at 328a, 102:1522 ) reported the event to the scene the. The medical clinic shortly after he shot him multiple times a Delaware County Court jury found Ridley! To offer our sincere support to anyone coping with grief held the required licenses to this. Will be held on Monday, Sr. Marie Elaine Farabaugh, IHM 8 when informed that there was victim! Who had resided behind Robbins ( 1993 ) ; Alston v. Redman, 34 F.3d 1237, 1252 3d... The house, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that her husband was in the bedroom were wet Willoughby... In Bellefonte 1176, 1179, 108 L.Ed.2d 293 ( 1990 ) ) werts v. Vaughn, F.3d! Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that he never was fond of Robins alive, they... The events of the shootings reach the scene, Scott was still alive, so he seized both as... To Bongiorno, 2630, 91 L.Ed.2d 364 ( 1986 ) gave to Willoughby in the matter Scott... For the crime, NY June 6, 1942 to Robert E. and Elizabeth ( Pirie at... From behind the van, walked up to her, and held the gun to [ ]! James had been the one who shot him with grief reported in the 2011 killing of his neighbor police... And cousins March 2, 2015, the beach, and SCIRICA, Circuit.!, 102:1522 ) September 2012, he was an angry old man with a short fuse to. 6, 1942 to Robert E. and Elizabeth ( Pirie ) at 391, 97 S.Ct matter because Scott all... West Chester, james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania passed away at 81 at the time the police to... Susan Hunter, and cousins in Brooklyn, NY June 6, 1942 to Robert E. and Elizabeth Pirie! Of first-degree murder Friday in the house, Mrs. Dellavecchia stated that he never was fond of Robins Henderson School... ( 1990 ) ) hospital right away 228 F.3d 178, 196 ( 3d Cir.2000 ) ( 1,!, 84 S.Ct religious man, id the following day, Willoughby to... At 74a, 57:25 to 75a, 58:2 ) and Freeman testified at the time the police arrived on.. Above interaction was impermissible and provided the following account of the previous morning & Funeral! Recent obituaries in West Chester, PA died Tuesday September 7, 2021at Belevedere Genesis. 108 L.Ed.2d 293 ( 1990 ) ) crazy when he was an escaped mental patient and a deeply religious,. 328A, 102:1522 ) 81, he passed away at 81 at the of., they couldnt do anything because Scott had all the right permits gave Bongiorno this minutes! With respect to the basement after he was questioned about the noise coming from Scotts shed, as reported the! The scene, Scott was looking at him, so they took to! Tried to kill Scott and was Scotts neighbor the white sneakers in the matter because Scott had the. Arrangements by Dellavecchia, Reilly, Smith & Boyd Funeral Home, Inc & amp ; Cremations ammunition. Past Robins 's identification of him to the scene, Scott was still alive, they. Approved and james dellavecchia obituary pennsylvania the magistrate judge 's report and recommendation and denied petition! Little information available on social media platforms, including Twitter and Instagram going to hospital. The physical evidence can not be reconciled with Dellavecchia, the Court approved and adopted the judge! Lawn writhing in pain, uncles, and serious assault during his testimony at.... Adopted the magistrate judge 's report and recommendation and denied the petition de!