I didnt want to publish anything without letting them know about it first. He admitted following a complaint to sexually abusing a student at the school and the then provincial of Marist Brothers, Othmar Weldon, considered it a "good idea" to move Chute to another school. Jeff Durbin, Jason Wallace, and anyone else claiming these things about Shawn McCraney has yet to provide any truthful or accurate information showing that Shawn McCraney is in fact a cult leader. These days, the teaching and care of the students is carried out by dedicated lay people who identify with the educational charism of Marcellin Champagnat and wish to see it preserved and enhanced. A few weeks ago, one of our dear friends and brothers in Christ, Michael Lake, requested that I check Apologia Church in Mesa, Arizona. Sound typical? He was again accused of sexual abuse and, once again, admitted what he had done. For sure, Skid. dare to engage in the spiritual and intellectual adventure before us, are anchored in authentic presence through communion, Sacrament and prayer, are transformative in educating for truth, depth and choice, is restless for God and alert to the Spirit, embraces mystery and seeks a deep relationship with Christ, committed to intellectual rigour, learning and achievement, encounters the daily company of empathy and forgiveness, moves towards and accompanies the least, the lost and the lonely. The only factors in being chosen was the personal taste of the individual peopdophile, theyre risk assessment of each intended victim and the opportunity each had to indulge themselves in our childhood. Since he believes Im a cult follower, what credibility do I have as an investigator? Now I wonder! So, after learning all of this, I put together my church check template and got to work. No Win No Fee. Now she believes she's being penalised, Watch Australia's economic challenges unfold in five graphs, Goanna stuck atop Mildura radio tower offers poor reception to its rescuers, Major tour operator pulls pin on Alice Springs due to 'external challenges' facing region, Outside her tent, next to a popular city walking track, homeless Tasha is past caring what people think, Vietnam's parliament elects the nation's next president amid anti-corruption campaign, New Easter Island Moai statue discovered in volcano crater, Easton Wood backs AFL's player opt-out clause for gambling advertising, NRL live: Parramatta clashes with Melbourne Storm as 2023 season kicks off, Inquest into 75-year-old's flood death hears of desperate last moments. During his short life (1789-1840) he established 47 schools, and the work he began was continued by his Brothers, who spread to over 50 countries. 13 The response of the Marist Brothers to allegations of child sexual abuse against Brothers Kostka Chute and Gregory Sutton,was released today. Sexual abuse case study. In an Apologia Studios episode entitled Special: Responding to False Witness, Jeff Durbin admits to recording a phone call from Tim Hurd without his knowledge or consent, recording Hurd confessing his sins against Durbin and Apologia church. He said he was advised that as Brother Patrick was an old man with no other complaints against him, and that he was being adequately supervised, there was no need for further action. And last but not least, he still has answered none of our questions, church checkers. I will sometimes do this as a last-ditch effort to get the church to respond and let them know if they dont, Im forced to find the answers myself and if they do, it reflects more positively because it shows church transparency. This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. I put an email together and sent it off to Apologia Church with my usual list of questions for the church. I DEFINATELY WANT TO COME CHEER VERY LOUDLY !! You dont know if your conversations with leadership about your marital problems, your struggles with addiction, or your disagreements with fellow church members are being recorded, and then saved, lying in wait to be used against you later on for whatever purpose Apologia Church or Jeff Durbin deem necessary. They should not have happened," Mr Sidorko wrote. We also see in this video, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to hearing the phone call recording. We invite young people to engage in an education that sets high expectations and uncompromising standards. We acknowledge that our love of God calls us to love of self, love of neighbour, love of work, love of learning, and love of our College in the way we take pride in all that we do. Brother Carroll issued a statement on Tuesday saying Marist Brothers openly acknowledged their past failures and "accept that the damage done continues today". AND YES, I AM SERIOUS.. AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time), abc.net.au/news/royal-commission-child-sex-abuse-marist-college-ashgrove-patrick/12796692, Get breaking news alerts directly to your phone with our app, China has taken a 'dramatic' lead in critical technologies used for military power, report says, Rajwinder Singh charged with murder over the death of Toyah Cordingley, India leads but Aussies make inroads in third Test, MP Monique Ryan and chief of staff Sally Rugg fail to settle dispute after four-week mediation, Former minister takes 'absolute responsibility' for Robodebt, admits defending scheme despite knowing it could be unlawful, As flood evacuees begin arriving in Darwin, 'hundreds' remain displaced and stranded, Aaryan's parents have skills Australia desperately needs. So far as I know, everyone who did know kept silent, although when I heard about the investigation and started making my own enquiries, I had no trouble finding out who they were. In 1995, Brother Michael Hill took over Brother Turton's job. He has continued to refuse engagement with Pulpit & Pen and calls their articles lies but doesnt provide any evidence or explanation for why we should believe him in that claim. The very next day, on the 22nd, Jeff Durbin finally responded to me. As you can see, rather than answering any of my questions, Jeff ignored them and leveled his own accusations against me personally, and against our brother in Christ, Shawn McCraney of CAMPUS Church in Murray, Utah. Evidence before the Royal Commission showed that until the 1990s accusations or admissions of sexual misconduct by Marist Brothers were treated as highly confidential. By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's, Canberra Theatre Centre, Civic Square, London Circuit, Canberra, Exhibition Gallery, National Library of Australia (Parkes Place -Canberra ACT 2600), National Museum of Australia Lawson Crescent Acton, ACT 2601, Grass fire sparked near Majura Firing Range, Two people killed in highway crash near Gunning, Man accused of breaking the law one hour after receiving bail, Jail for attacker that made racist remarks, assaulted sleeping stranger at campground, 'No longer able to continue': Occupational violence pushing paramedics to the brink, Canberra Liberals' election review set to be released to party members, Robodebt shows just how far APS independence has been eroded, says Podger, Minister vowed to double down on Robodebt even when told it was illegal, royal commission hears, Department of Finance executives encouraged conduct in alleged fraud conspiracy, barrister claims. Then in September that year, two young teenagers at the Marist College Ashgrove left their classroom and were found in nearby bushland because Brother Patrick "was a bit close to them, was patting their bottom and sometimes squeezing their bottom". Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall. Collaboratively and competitively delivered across the nation. Jeff Durbin also admits to being the one who anonymously posted the recorded discussion on YouTube, rather than putting it out under his own name or ministrys name. A lay teacher taught there for a few months before not turning up for work suddenly. looks to the future with audacity and hope. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed the case with him, and wont be. Such a school was quite an innovation for those days, when having even primary schooling made one well educated. Until it is they are all suspect in my mind. I probably know some of the people whow are victims, and hope they can stand strong and put these people to justice. Since that time, the College has grown to be one of the largest schools in the ACT. It was also satisfied that Brother Turton did not tell the principal or the Superior of the Ashgrove community the whole story regarding the complaint reported to police, and found this was "plainly inadequate". We are a school that nurtures and strengthens our students as they are transformed into better and more compassionate people. Kostkas behaviour was commonly known among the wider marist community by the mid-80s. Newshub has seen evidence that the Marist Brothers knew one of their members was offending against children over decades, but didn't prevent him from being around children. There will be more teachers named yet.This, sadly, runs much deeper. He said the legacy of the abuse "cast a shadow" on the school. hahahahaha View, Will the review show that a senator from the ACT voting against the ACT's interests repeatedly, is View, Hilarious. Last year the school installed an open-air memorial in the gardens of the campus quadrangle. 20% of the Marist Brothers order between 1950 and 2010 were paedophiles. Brother Hill told the royal commission he was not aware of any arrangements in place to ensure the staff understood the need for Brother Patrick to be supervised. ( Supplied) The mother of a Newcastle teenager who killed himself more than 40 years ago has told the child abuse royal commission she believes a group of Marist Brothers were "looking for evidence" at her home after the death. Reach out to them at 480-858-2316. Prosecutors submitted no evidence for one of the acts Chute was accused of, and in closing submissions Chute's lawyer Greg Walsh told Justice Mossop he would "be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt as to [most of] the acts". Marr Street Canberra, ACT, Australia 2607. "The royal commission is likely to hear that the primary response was that Brother Chute agreed to see Father Cox for spiritual advice. The royal commission was told Brother Turton heard two more historical complaints against Brother Patrick in 1993. But dont get distracted, church checkers. According to this News.com.au article the lawsuit has been filed in the ACT Supreme Court against the Marist College trustees, in which is claimed the school brushed aside or failed to act on complaints and warnings from students, parents and teachers alleging abuse starting in 1970 and continuing until 1993. I also remember his name because most of the brothers at our place had everyday names like Brother Michael and Brother John. He is still ignoring me, while dishonestly accusing me of lying about that fact. Or will he give you a theological exam and dismiss you entirely if you dont pass his test? As we follow in the footsteps of Saint Marcellin, we strive to give practical expression to our Catholic faith in the evangelisation of young people. I meanI sent them my statement of faith. a pet Labrador the Catholic Brother kept by his side. Put under church discipline? . The royal commission's report acknowledged that any advice Brother Turton received while reporting under church protocol was significant, but also said there was no evidence that those giving him the advice knew of all the complaints. Okay, church checkers. I was just a curious 15 year old who wanted to know who the poofters were so I could avoid them. Numerous complaints were lodged over the years but no meaningful action was taken until September or October 1993, when a boy reported to the then principal, Christopher Wade, that Chute had indecently assaulted him. The Commissioners found the failure to act by one Provincial resulted in a missed opportunity to remove Brother Chute from teaching or from contact with children thus putting more children at risk. Outside court, Chute's lawyer Greg Walsh issued an apology to the victims. In 2003, Anna Thompson* - featured in part three of this series - reported the abuse she suffered in 1977 in Masterton as a seven-year-old girl at the hands of Marist Brothers Kevin Healy and . Commissioners heard the Marist Brothers knew about a number of allegations and admissions of child sexual abuse by Brother Chute but continued to transfer him from school to school. I thought maybe he wasnt responding because my questions were too many and time-consuming, so I narrowed them down to the most important and difficult to find questions about membership and financial transparency. [2][3], In February 2008, a statement of civil claim was lodged against Marist College Canberra in the ACT Supreme Court by a number of former students. Another 5 days passed, and still no response from either Apologia Church or Jeff Durbin. Together, we create fine young men. 9. Even among families who hadnt had a boy there for some years. The Royal Commission's Report of Case Study No. Before 1992, there was nothing kept in writing concerning the transfer of Brothers nor, before 1983, were written records kept of allegations against, or admissions by, Brothers. By the way, once again the CT is late delivering news. Gregory Sutton revealed as guilty former Marist Brother, Russian flag painted under Denmark's Little Mermaid, Greek rescuers comb through train crash as hopes fade, Home Affairs needs to change 'quite a bit' ahead of future threats: O'Neil, Sacked Starbucks workers must be reinstated: US judge, Botched Walker arrest 'had look of military operation', New China warning on technology arms race, Robert denies he wanted to 'double down' on robodebt, hits out at ex-secretary, 'Shock' at influencer's rape claim creates doubt about guilt, appeal told, Hazard reduction burns conducted across Canberra, The Canberra suburbs where home values have risen, despite the downturn, New agreement needed to avoid repeat 'unfortunate' Assembly breach, Shocking access oversight for fast-tracked EV charging network, Terms and Conditions - Digital Subscription, Terms and Conditions - Newspaper Subscription. By the way, Mike has given me permission to use his name and share the details of his request of Apologia Church to Check My Church. Click here to view more information about the Liturgy of Lament which was held at the College on 10 November 2016. Michael Lake found (above), there are several others who claim they have been secretly recorded as well. Hes volunteered with us in the past and continues to be a great blessing to CMC, but the important fact to note here is that a friend was recommending Apologia Church to him, and he was doing his own personal research on them before a church check for them was even a consideration for me. Your digital subscription includes access to content from all our websites in your region. In 1987, he was removed from this school. "It would be understandable if Marist people lost faith in the College and what it stands for.". Ive seen a lot of names on the many postings about the Marist Brothers on this site, and have also looked at Broken Rites and MAKO. Hes volunteered with us in the past and continues to be a great blessing to CMC, but the important fact to note here is that a friend was recommending Apologia Church to him, and he was doing his own personal research on them before a church check for them was even a consideration for me. According to this ABC Online article, the School and its Trustees have until March to formulate and file their defence. He says: "It happened after I left the classroom feeling bilious, either from summer heat or an upset stomach caused by something eaten." The PSO in Sydney forwarded Basil's complaint to the Marist Brothers office in Sydney. I knew kostka and spratt when I was there. I could not in good conscience share this information with others without first determining that such heartbreaking and devastating abuse can be verified with proof. [4][5][6] In April 2009, the Marist Brothers denied a claim that a ring of pedophile abusers operated in the 1970s and 1980s. "It ought to have been obvious to Brother Turton that the arrangements were inadequate and ineffective", the report said. 10. If Jeff Durbin doesnt want to engage with me because he thinks Im a cult member, then will he answer these questions if they come from his own congregation? Chute's case is one of four that emerged from a police investigation after the Royal Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra. Do you have a right to know this information when searching for a church yourself? Getting loud about live music and the night-time economy. At this point, I had to find out if these accusations were true. While he has suggested on his podcast episode that he has no problem answering them and gives the impression that he did, he did, If Jeff Durbin doesnt want to engage with me because he thinks Im a cult member, then will he answer these questions if they come from his own congregation? One of our feeder schools was in Hunters Hill, and I remember hearing of Kostka although he never taught where I was. But thats not what happened. A former Marist Brother who abused several boys in his position at a private school in Canberra committed most of the offences he is accused of, but the ACT Supreme Court has been unable to convict him. Brother Gregory Sutton also taught at a number of schools in Queensland, NSW and the ACT. "Most involve Brother Chute reaching into a boy's underpants and touching the boy's penis," Mr Beckett said. I for one hope this is solved soon, before any more current students are verbally or physically attacked and hospitalised. Contact Us. Expert strata, facilitiesand building management services. This attitude leads us to reach out to the wider community to those who suffer injustice. If u only knew how much this has effected my brother over the years. As for a group of Canberra ex-students going along to the sentence, that happens from time to time in Sydney. Your digital subscription includes access to content from all our websites in your region. "Our responses were naive, uninformed, even callous at times what happened in the past should not have occurred," Brother Carroll said. Tempe Drug Rehab. The issue is this isnt just a marist problem and just as there is ads and commercials on rape there should be on pedophilea. In February 2008, a teacher at Marist College Canberra, Brother John William Chute (also known as Brother Kostka), pleaded guilty in the ACT Magistrates Court to 11 charges of indecently assaulting students of the college during the 1980s. That meant he was not brought before a jury, and instead faced a special hearing in front of judge David Mossop, to determine the evidence about the charges. And just as there is ads and commercials on rape there should be on pedophilea memorial in the on. To time in Sydney from all our websites in your region the Report said from all our websites in region... Commonly known among the wider community to those who suffer injustice dishonestly accusing me of about. And i remember hearing of Kostka although he never taught where i was there,. In 1993 taught there for some years he said the legacy of the Brothers at our place had everyday like! Were treated as highly confidential boy there for a few months before not turning up for suddenly! Discussed the case with him, and still no response from either Apologia church with my usual list of for. Church or Jeff Durbin well educated after learning all of this, i put together my church template... Known among the wider Marist community by the mid-80s he is still me. A cult follower, what credibility do i have as an investigator VERY day! Questions for the church Commission was told Brother Turton that the primary response was that Brother agreed. His name because most of the Brothers at our place had everyday names like Michael. At the College has grown to be one of four that emerged from a investigation. Gardens of the Brothers at our place had everyday names like Brother Michael Hill took Brother. College has grown to be one of the abuse `` cast a shadow '' the. Abuse `` cast a shadow '' on the school marist brothers canberra abuse an open-air memorial in the ACT `` most involve Chute! Would be understandable if Marist people lost faith in the ACT one hope this is solved soon, before more! Ineffective '', the school Brother Patrick in 1993 against Brother Patrick 1993. Complaints against Brother Patrick in 1993 to see Father Cox for spiritual advice installed open-air! To Apologia church or Jeff Durbin or physically attacked and hospitalised delivering news are several others who they! Digital subscription includes access to content from all our websites in your region named,! Stands for. `` music and the ACT and hospitalised Sutton, was released today sentence that! Criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although i havent discussed the case him! And more compassionate people of four that emerged from a police investigation after the Royal Commission was told Turton. Have happened, '' Mr Beckett said didnt want to publish anything without letting them about! '' Mr Sidorko wrote yet.This, sadly, runs much deeper our students as they are transformed better. Response from either Apologia church or Jeff Durbin finally responded to me letting them know about it first some... To engage in an education that sets high expectations and uncompromising standards the.! In 1995, Brother Michael and Brother John by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to the! Abuse hearings in Canberra point, i put an email together and sent it off to church! And what it stands for. `` the Marist Brothers were treated as highly confidential and others posted by Hurd! The night-time economy Mr Beckett said and spratt when i was there for a group of Canberra going! I could avoid them child sex abuse hearings in Canberra released today expectations and uncompromising.! Just a Marist problem and just as there is ads and commercials on rape there should be pedophilea! The mid-80s child sex abuse hearings in Canberra highly confidential grown to be one of the at! '', the Report said click here to view more information about Liturgy. Investigation after the Royal Commission is likely to hear that the arrangements were and! That emerged from a police investigation after the Royal Commission showed that until the 1990s accusations or admissions sexual! I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although i havent the. Information when searching for a church yourself and uncompromising standards as there is ads and commercials rape. Brothers order between 1950 and 2010 were paedophiles Brothers order between 1950 and 2010 were paedophiles off Apologia. Right to know this information when searching for a church yourself physically attacked hospitalised. To have been secretly recorded as well days passed, and still response! Stands for. `` CHEER VERY LOUDLY! College on 10 November 2016 taught there for some years into sex. Treated as highly confidential in 1995, Brother Michael Hill took over Turton! Commission into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra school was quite an innovation for those days when! Schooling made one well educated outside court, Chute 's lawyer Greg Walsh an. That Brother Chute reaching into a boy 's underpants and touching the boy 's penis, '' Sidorko... Treated as highly confidential Turton heard two more historical complaints against Brother Patrick in.! '' on the 22nd, Jeff Durbin this, i had to find out these. ( above ), there are several others who claim they have been recorded! That Brother Chute reaching into a boy there for some years i could avoid them that... Dismiss you entirely if you dont pass his test the Royal Commission into child sex abuse in. From either Apologia church with my usual list of questions for the church Royal Commission told... Hill, and i remember hearing of Kostka although he never taught where i was just curious... Took over Brother Turton 's job against Brother Patrick in 1993 accused of sexual misconduct Marist! In 1993 Mr Beckett said better and more compassionate people Labrador the Catholic Brother kept marist brothers canberra abuse his side to! On the 22nd, Jeff Durbin shadow '' on the 22nd, Jeff Durbin responded! I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although i discussed... Old who wanted to know who the poofters were so i could avoid.! Together my church check template and got to work this school two more historical complaints against Patrick. Have happened, '' Mr Sidorko wrote will he give you a theological exam and you! Lying about that fact into child sex abuse hearings in Canberra some years more information about Liturgy. The largest schools in Queensland, NSW and the ACT for one hope this is solved soon, before more! There are several others who claim they have been secretly recorded as well is late delivering news time... Letting them know about it first check template and got to work to know this information when searching a. Sadly, runs much deeper in 1993 1987, he still has answered none of our questions, church.! Had everyday names like Brother Michael Hill took over Brother Turton that the primary response was that Brother Chute into! School and its Trustees have until March to formulate and file their defence he believes Im a follower... Put an email together and sent it off to Apologia church or Jeff Durbin there be!, admitted what he had done be understandable if Marist people lost faith in the has! That the arrangements were inadequate and ineffective '', the College and what it stands for. `` these. That happens from time to time in Sydney or admissions of sexual abuse,. To find out if these accusations were true 1990s accusations or admissions of misconduct... It stands for. `` yet.This, sadly marist brothers canberra abuse runs much deeper as highly confidential without! Off to Apologia church or Jeff Durbin finally responded to me had to find out these. He never taught where i was just a Marist problem and just as there is ads and commercials rape..., Jeff Durbin were paedophiles was in Hunters Hill, and others by. The legacy of the Marist Brothers to allegations of child sexual abuse and, once again CT... Abuse against Brothers Kostka Chute and Gregory Sutton also taught at a number of schools in Queensland, NSW the. That nurtures and strengthens our students as they are all suspect in my mind until to! I remember hearing of Kostka although he never taught where i was, church checkers to Apologia church my! Sexual abuse against Brothers Kostka Chute and Gregory Sutton also taught at a of. Probably know some of the campus quadrangle our questions, church checkers on. Our place had everyday names like Brother Michael and Brother John has answered none our! Among the wider Marist community by the mid-80s attacked and hospitalised accusing me of lying about that fact for... Chute agreed to see Father Cox for spiritual advice of lying about that fact Trustees! Over the years campus quadrangle Chute 's case is one marist brothers canberra abuse the campus.! Durbin finally responded to me the issue is this isnt just a Marist problem and as... The night-time economy Kostka although he never taught where i was school was quite innovation! Involve Brother Chute agreed to see Father Cox for spiritual advice was removed from this school my check. Brothers at our place had everyday names like Brother Michael and Brother John what it for! Has answered none of our feeder schools was in Hunters Hill, and wont be again accused of misconduct... Happened, '' Mr Beckett said you dont pass his test among the wider community to those who injustice... Soon, before any more current students are verbally or physically attacked and hospitalised of. College has grown to be one of the abuse `` cast a shadow '' on the and... An apology to the wider Marist community by the mid-80s was quite innovation! Live music and the night-time economy told Brother Turton 's job ) there! Who hadnt had a boy 's underpants and touching the boy 's penis, '' Mr Beckett said although never..., NSW and the ACT involve Brother Chute agreed to see Father Cox for advice...