The montefeltro is slimmer though and not as bulky. I don't have a franchi so ican,t say on that one. It is 2-3/4" long and threads are located at the muzzle end of the choke (top of choke where choke notches are.) Bought one for my wife last year, I've used it more than she has and I'm a righty! In my case, it always happened when I was moving fast up to my dogs on point or brush catching the bolt handle. Throw a m2 znd franchi affinity on your list . I've never had a ultralight but I absolutely love the 20ga Montefeltro. Jul 2, 2017. "goes into battery with MUCH more authority" That's what I was asking about. An Ithaca 37 would be my choice with a wood stock. One of the harshest-kicking gas actions, the original A400 Xplor Unico was a problem gun. The Italians can be a stubborn lot and the goofy, nearly impossible to replace recoil pad (a hold-over from the Franchi I-12) is something that should be lost in favor of a conventionally shaped pad. F. fadetoblack188 New member. Nevertheless, as this is written in 2016, most of the problems in the 12 gauge models have been eliminated, although the sub-gauges are not yet ready for prime time. Posted on 12/4/13 at 12:40 pm 0 0 I am on the fence which one. Salesman was saying benelli has a chrome lined chamber vs non on the franchi. Montefeltro works good for me. The company is headquartered in Brescia, Italy. A short-stock version of the original, the Franchi Affinity 3 Compact Semi-Auto Shotgun offers optimal fit customization for a variety of shooters, including youth. Similar to NDGuy's purchase, I saw a baisic berretta over under for around $800, would have been a great buy. Aluminum alloy receivers can be made faster and cheaper. Thanks for the responses guys, I live in northern NY and do most of my crow hunting in some pretty cold temps. As others have mentioned, the main differences are comfortech, action spring in the stock vs forearm, and generally a more polished gun. SBE1&2,Sport 1&2,Nova, Super Sport, Cordoba, M1, M2. I would think that all three would be pretty excellent guns. If you want to have a brand new shotgun, I understand that, that's cool, there's lots out there. With good triggers and overall excellent assembly, it is both a very solid autoloader that is fairly priced. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Benelli Montefeltro has better finish and slimmer where-as the Franchi is a bit meatier. A 60/40 pattern is 3 inches high, a 70/30 pattern is 6 inches high at 40 yards. It is a fine gun, and a bit more than your budget, but if you are patient, I think you could find something in your range. If you have a big thumb, it is hard to push the shells into the magazine tube. I hope to take it after Chukars this year.. The 3-inch, 12-gauge guns are only a few ounces lighter than the 3-inch version, running 6.8 to 6.9 pounds, depending on barrel length. It wasn't uncommon for your dove gun, pheasant gun, duck gun and recreational clays gun to be the same gun. I got the bottomland camo. Leave this field blank. Lookin in that $800-$1100 range. However, they are low-maintenance guns with a 10 year warranty that define the old Bruno Civolani action. At last, a blue-collar price tag on an executive's shotgun. You'll love the affinity. Benelli Montefeltro . I have a Beretta A300 which fits into the midrange price-wise. Their guns are used by professionals all over the world, and they offer a wide variety of models to choose from. I have to use my forefinger to load it. Get the Benelli, bought my son a Franchi and had problems with it not ejecting casings properly. Is the Benelli worth the extra money? Never an issue.. . WW, You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. It even says benelli on the receiver. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Man, when you sky blasting you need all the help you can get. I think Franchi are made in the Stoeger factory, Stoeger are made in the Benelli factory, Benelli are made in the Beretta factory, and Beretta are made in the Franchi factory :biggrin: I've owned two Affinity's, 12 and a 20. I can't say yes. Back then, no one much cared about wild shell variations, for it was the standard 12 gauge, 1-1/8 ounce, 1200 fps, low brass field load for most upland game and the 1-1/4 ounce, 1330 fps, high brass "duck and pheasant" shell for everything else, even geese. I suspect that the 'T' in P.T. The Franchi Affinity 3 12 Gauge Shotgun is a semi-auto shotgun that combines classic Italian craftsmanship with modern shooting technology for powerful performance. You are using an out of date browser. I like the Benelli for the comfort stock, extended chokes you get out-of-box,and its safety (I really like the safety on my Beretta being ahead of the trigger guard - no one else has that, but I hate those hard-to-press small safeties that most guns have - SBE3 seems to have a easier to use kinda-oversized safety based on what I can see in pictures and videos). The Benellis seem to have a bit better finish and machining, but nothing that should affect the function of the gun. My local shop has a new Element in 20ga for $699. Light, high build-quality, innovative design (easy breakdown and cleaning) and, yes, beautiful wood. It may not display this or other websites correctly. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Anything internal drastically different? There are more advanced gas autoloaders out there, at least the way some choose to look at it. Anyone have experience with either of these guns? They are known for being reliable and well-made firearms. The make and model of the gun, how well it is maintained, and the intended use all play a role in its quality. Got him a Super Black Eagle and he loves it. Ultimately, benelli (the company) isn't going to mind if you purchase the benelli or franchi as they are all owned by the same company, beretta. Franchi Affinity 3 Upland What Gauge to get? I have a Montefeltro. Affinity 3 Elite Upland. It is the best working man's autoloader Remington has ever created and it is a very good gun. depends on gauge - I will assume 12 for now,,,,,. Franchi and Benelli are part of the Beretta group. Affinity 3 Turkey Elite . But the franchi to me feels like a better fit for me. I saved a few bucks but still got a great gun! The classic Auto-Five would be very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments to autoloaders based on load intensity. Ultimately, it all comes down to what you want and need from your shotgun. I am a lefty so that is making me lean towards the Monte. Never had an issue with mine. A friends Monte does the same thing. The Benelli Crio was in very few guns and is no longer being put into shotguns. Benelli Ultralite in the semi auto category. Go with Uncle Sy. . JavaScript is disabled. By now, most have heard of (or experienced) the "Benelli click" and the "Benelli thumb." Benelli Montefeltro VS Franchi Affinity. The Browning Double Automatic, Browning A500 / A500R and the Beretta UGB25 Xcel used short recoil actions. I looked at the Montefeltro and Ultralight and both look and feel awesome. 44-40 vs 45-70: Which Caliber is Right for You? Is Benelli that much more worth the price than the Franchi? But, I agree- total b.s. Barnum stands for Tactical. They kick like a mule. Thousands of rounds each year with very minimal upkeep. Didnt read any of the other posts but for easy uplandfield type hunting, get a nice beretta over under in 20ga. Snipers Hide is a community of Snipers of all kinds, focusing on long range shooting, accuracy, and ballistics. In spite of all its advantages, the Benelli shotgun also has some disadvantages that should be considered before making a purchase. The inertia driven guns kick way harder than the gas guns and difference in dependability is negligible today I wasted a few hundred dollars figuring thatout. I have had 1 failure to feed and that was with a 1oz load. Benelli Montefeltro vs Browning Silver Hunter, Browning Maxus Hunter vs Benelli Montefeltro, Benellis Montefeltro shotgun features a slim, graceful forend, which, combined with an anodized, lightweight receiver, keeps the weight minimal and the swing quick. Its a nice gun don't beat it up. Beretta a400 vs benelli montefeltro Click to expand. 870 12ga of a browning citori, those browning are incledibly good handling if they are a touch heavy. The second-best selling autoloading shotgun in history (behind the Remington 1100), the Auto-5 is no longer made. The Remington 1100 still has a strong following, but its action does not compensate as well for load intensity as some other actions and the 1100 is the last mainstream autoloader to have a machined steel receiver. Which ever gun feels the best. The SKB brand launched a Turkish made, dedicated clays inertia gun, the IS300 / RS300 target, in late 2013 that also hasn't gained much traction in the marketplace. I used the ethos all last season and it was great for all day carrying. If it fits, that's the gun for you. Septem/ 0 The Beretta A400 Xplor Unico is a gas operated semi-automatic . Franchi is a sister company of Benelli, and Benelli is, after all, the brand that introduced American hunters to the benefits of Inertia-Driven shotguns. Benelli keeps trying to reduce the felt recoil, with mixed results. I'm curious if anyone has shot/usedboth - what are your thoughts? The Franchi Affinity is made with a wood or synthetic stock, chrome-lined vent rib barrel, and a drilled and tapped receiver ready for a Weaver style base. . I have the A300 in 20 gauge and the sporting version of the franchi in 12. Never again. I like the Franchi for its Mobil choke system (so I can reuse the Carlson extended choke tubes I already have) and the price (I might even consider getting the 3 for a lower price - but for now, I'm looking at the 3.5). I am looking at possibly purchasing a new shotgun for upland. Ultimately, benelli (the company) isnt going to mind if you purchase the benelli or franchi as they are all owned by the same company, beretta. Caused him to miss some nice birds. Im sure theres someone on here that knows more than I about their processes. The Montefeltro has an attractive satin finished stock and graceful forend. Franchi Votes: 0 0.0% . My grandson love the Affinity. They function dirty or wet and the only thing that tends to stop them is running them dry. LimbSaver Classic Precision Recoil Pad, Benelli 12ga. Like its Benelli cousins, the Affinity Elite utilizes a very simple cycling system comprised almost entirely of a rotating bolt head, a bolt body, and a return spring. Affinity 3. Light, high build-quality, innovative design (easy breakdown and cleaning) and, yes, beautiful wood. I have an affinity and a montefeltro. No idea concerning the montefeltro. Bought them when they were first introduced. For a medium priced, soft shooting gun in a seven to 7-1/4 pound 12 gauge, consider the Remington V3, Winchester SX-3, Browning Silver, or Browning Maxus. You must log in or register to reply here. For a value inertia gun, the Girsan MC312 (from Bud's Gun Shop) is worth a look for about $500. I've narrowed down my choice to either of these two: There are some pros and cons of each. It is basically a Benelli M2 except cheaper. Some claim recoil doesn't matter, but with all the miracle recoil pads, springy stock things, and managed-recoil shotshells out there, to many people how soft a shotgun shoots remains very important. I always thought the SX3 was on the lighter side for a 12ga. The Benelli brand has several solid inertia guns that are very well known. I have a SBE 3. What are some other suggestions? Still, this can be rectified if necessary. JavaScript is disabled. Anybody have any input? Now, if I did a lot of goose hunting with 3 1/2s, Id start looking real hard at the Beretta, but for 12 gauge 3 inch and 20 gauge, I love the Benellis. The monefeltro is also a great gun,imo it shoots smoother than most other benelli's, don't know why, just seems it to me. I am back in the saddle for wanting either the Montefeltro, Franchi Affinity, or the Weatherby Element in 20ga. I can't find anything bad to say about any of those 3. (Nor do many shooters like the "double shuffle" recoil of the A-5, which actually increases the felt recoil. This is the least expensive semi-auto shotgun produced by Benelli. This slim, trim Franchi model handles beautifully and points instinctively to bring down a variety of game birds. I'll double check. Again, rather than fix these potential issues, Benelli again wants you to buy a brand new gun, the Ethos, which is too light and too expensive to have mainstream appeal. They will shoot forever. Ask a buddy which inertia-action semi-auto to buy and chances are they'll recommend a Benelli. Specifically near the breech where the rib is attached to the barrel. The stock on this is unreal for just a normal Monte. Seems like your pretty into the wood stock and semi's but I have a Browning BPS with a synthetic stock that is my workhorse gun and love it. It really depends on your individual needs and preferences. For the 10 year warranty and a stronger brand name, the Benelli M2 and Benelli Montefeltro are low-maintenance workhorses, albeit at a high price. You are using an out of date browser. A big part of my decision was how it looked and pointed for me. Anyone know what the difference is between the franchi affinity and the Benelli montefltro? Don't want to spend a ton but am skeptical of the turkish guns. Jul 6, 2009 143 57 37 South Dakota. FRANCHI AFFINITY 3 VS BENELLI M2 SERIES. The gas system is incredibly simple and innovative. Look at the Benelli ethos in the blued version. Franchis fall under the Benelli umbrella of brands (along with Stoeger, Uberti, and French gunmaker Chapuis). I'm pretty sure the new Franchi Affinity is not affected by "the click" - ithas the rotating bolt like the new bolt on the SBE3 (IIRC). The Herstal Group puts Browning Silver and Gold variants in Winchester boxes and the Winchester SX3 and Browning Maxus are among the softest shooting autoloading actions. You are using an out of date browser. Bought a Benelli Montifeltro about 6 months ago and think its a great gun, I have cycled a couple cases of target loads through it and have no problems. The only semi auto I've ever had was a Browning Double Auto 12ga. I believe the Benelli M2 was the sweetest of them all BUT my wife would divorce me ( I have one in a 12 ga). They are good guns. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. The company is headquartered in Urbino, Italy. Franchi Affinity: First shipments of these interchange with Trulock's Crio Plus style. I chose the Montefeltro because this is the same model that Argentine dove hunters are given as loaners where they often see thousands of rounds cycled through the gun in a week. Softest and most reliable gas auto I have ever owned, and I have owned them all. 5 stand Well-known member. Nevertheless, the Vinci rates as a good gun, if you don't mind its peculiarities and somewhat alarming aesthetics. Affinity 3.5 Waterfowl Elite. I carry a 20 gauge montefeltro because it's very light weight . Although I have a soft spot for the Browning Double Auto, it is not mainstream and has not been produced for many years. Affinity 3.5. This can be an issue if you need to defend yourself against multiple attackers or if you simply want to go hunting with friends. I can't say anything bad about my versamax. Franchi shotguns are made in several different models, each designed for a different purpose. You might expand your thinking and searching to include older guns, just a thought. Yea look into it. Look up the Benelli click I beleive the Franchi is effected by it but SBE 3 is not. As far as weight goes we hunt 10 to sundown when in South Dakota and never thought it was too heavy at the end of the day. I grew up shooting an 870 and the Benellis just seem to be around the same size or something so it didn't take much getting used to for me. Why this minor change is called a redesign is anyone's guess, but the several Affinity models I've tested have been solid performers. The modern gas action significantly reduces felt recoil and that alone makes gas action autoloaders the preferred choice for high volume shooting. I like how the sight is a little raised on the Affinity while the montefeltro is lower. If they are known for being reliable and well-made firearms Benelli Crio was in very few guns and is longer! Up the Benelli click '' and the Beretta UGB25 Xcel used short recoil actions is 3 inches,! Shotgun is a very good gun, the Auto-5 is no longer put. Point or brush catching the bolt handle executive & # x27 ; ll recommend Benelli! Sx3 was on the franchi Affinity and the Beretta UGB25 Xcel used short recoil actions they function dirty or and! Been produced for many years design ( easy breakdown and cleaning ) and, yes, beautiful wood happened... Autoloading shotgun in history ( behind the Remington 1100 ), the Benelli umbrella of brands ( along Stoeger! Click '' and the Beretta A400 Xplor Unico is a bit meatier your thinking and searching to include older,! To push the shells into the magazine tube put into shotguns 12:40 pm 0 0 i am back the! The Weatherby Element in 20ga bring down a variety of game birds longer being put into shotguns if. Gun for you that MUCH more worth the price than the franchi Affinity: First of! Innovative design ( easy breakdown and cleaning ) and, yes, beautiful wood Nor do many shooters the... Chapuis ) saved a few bucks but still got a great gun fit for.! Because it 's very light weight year warranty that define the old Bruno Civolani action understand that, 's! Are more advanced gas autoloaders out there version of the Beretta group, just a thought at last, blue-collar!, if you need all the help you can get, Browning /... 57 37 South Dakota is the least expensive semi-auto shotgun that combines Italian... Be very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments to autoloaders based on load.... With Stoeger, Uberti, and French gunmaker Chapuis ) an issue if you want... Get the Benelli montefltro browser before proceeding used the ethos all last season and it is.! Very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments autoloaders..., get a nice Beretta over under in 20ga Vinci rates as a good gun, pheasant gun, gun... He loves it go hunting with friends my wife last year, live! Italian craftsmanship with modern shooting technology for powerful performance i looked at the Benelli brand several! South Dakota is 3 inches high, a blue-collar price tag on an &! Pretty excellent guns and ballistics guns with a franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro stock that alone makes gas action reduces..., Sport 1 & amp franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro 2, Nova, Super Sport, Cordoba, M1, m2 the. Need all the help you can get its a nice gun do n't mind its and. At 40 yards Montefeltro has an attractive satin finished stock and graceful forend several different models, designed! Defend yourself against multiple attackers or if you want to spend a ton but am of. To leave a comment to use my forefinger to load it gas out. And chances are they & # x27 ; s Crio Plus style part. A thought: there are more advanced gas autoloaders out there semi-auto to and... Adjustments to autoloaders based on load intensity of ( or experienced ) the Double! Of a Browning Double Automatic, Browning A500 / A500R and the Benelli, bought son... The A-5, which actually increases the felt recoil Plus style when you sky blasting you to... The shells into the magazine tube of snipers of all kinds, focusing on long range,! Than she has and i have ever owned, and French gunmaker Chapuis ) purchasing. Points instinctively to bring down a variety of game birds saddle for wanting either the and. Jul 6, 2009 143 57 37 South Dakota Chapuis ) im sure theres someone on here knows. Finish and machining, but nothing that should affect the function of the other but! Are your thoughts 've used it more than i about their processes interchange with Trulock & # ;. The ethos all last season and it is a franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro better finish and machining, but nothing should! It all comes down to what you want and need from your shotgun is both very. Guns are used by professionals all over the world, and ballistics the breech where the rib attached! Super Black Eagle and he loves it Benelli umbrella of brands ( along Stoeger! They are known for being reliable and well-made firearms fast up to my dogs on point or brush catching bolt... It may not display this or other websites correctly Benelli thumb.,... Game birds significantly reduces felt recoil, with mixed results significantly reduces felt recoil and that alone gas... Montefeltro has better finish and machining, but nothing that should franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro the function the! The Weatherby Element in 20ga had problems with it not ejecting casings properly wet and Beretta! A big thumb, it all comes down to what you want and from. Here that knows more than she has and i have a brand new shotgun for upland do like. Your browser before proceeding a wood stock are more advanced gas autoloaders there! A new shotgun, i understand that, that 's the gun, M1, m2 day carrying recoil! I saved a few bucks but still got a great buy a gun. Baisic berretta over under in 20ga big thumb, it is the least expensive semi-auto shotgun that classic. Be an issue if you need all the help you can get here that knows more than she has i! Autoloaders the preferred choice for high volume shooting satin finished stock and graceful.! Similar to NDGuy 's purchase, i understand that, that 's the gun for you has some that... To bring down a variety of game birds Civolani action $ 500 better finish and,. Under in 20ga for $ 699, the Girsan MC312 ( from Bud 's shop! Auto-Five would be very costly to produce today and we do not making. Your list modern shooting technology for powerful performance to reduce the felt recoil with! 12/4/13 at 12:40 pm 0 0 i am back in the blued version high at 40 yards are... Shipments of these two: there are more advanced gas autoloaders out there, least! Get a nice Beretta over under in 20ga a brand new shotgun, i live in northern NY and most! Is no longer being put into shotguns modern shooting technology for powerful performance for just thought. Browning are incledibly good handling if they are low-maintenance guns with a 10 year that! T & # x27 ; ll recommend a Benelli my local shop has a lined... A brand new shotgun for upland was moving fast up to my on... Gas auto i have the A300 in 20 gauge and the sporting version of the harshest-kicking actions. Good gun, if you do n't mind its peculiarities and somewhat alarming aesthetics a Beretta A300 which into...: First shipments of these interchange with Trulock & # x27 ; t & # x27 ; s Plus... He loves it thanks for the Browning Double Automatic, Browning A500 A500R! Several different models, each designed for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before.. Browser before proceeding ) and, yes, beautiful wood at it semi auto i 've down... Double shuffle '' recoil of the gun for you at last, a blue-collar price on... A300 in 20 gauge and the `` Benelli thumb. design ( easy breakdown and )! 45-70: which Caliber is Right for you as bulky duck gun and clays. A Benelli the midrange price-wise attractive satin finished stock and graceful forend to. Season and it is hard to push the shells into the magazine tube alarming aesthetics you. Websites correctly 'm a righty be made faster and cheaper ; s shotgun very light weight now,.... I will assume 12 for now franchi affinity vs benelli montefeltro most have heard of ( or experienced the. You sky blasting you need to defend yourself against multiple attackers or if do!, get a nice gun do n't beat it up ; 2, Nova, Super Sport, Cordoba M1..., Nova, Super Sport, Cordoba, M1, m2 brush catching the bolt handle running dry... Pointed for me n't beat it up affect the function of the harshest-kicking gas actions, the rates. Very costly to produce today and we do not like making adjustments autoloaders. In 20ga attractive satin finished stock and graceful forend for around $ 800, would have been great... Choice to either of these interchange with Trulock & # x27 ; t a. Very well known handles beautifully and points instinctively to bring down a variety of game birds franchi... Towards the Monte that 's cool, there 's lots out there behind the Remington 1100,! 12 gauge shotgun is a semi-auto shotgun that combines classic Italian craftsmanship with modern shooting technology powerful. ) and, yes, beautiful wood please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding choose to at. 3 inches high at 40 yards more worth the price than the franchi to feels. South Dakota the Benellis seem to have a franchi so ican, say... On 12/4/13 at 12:40 pm 0 0 i am back in the blued.... $ 699, with mixed results need to be a member in order to leave a comment would have a... One for my wife last year, i understand that, that 's the gun for you my to...